Modern Times

On May 15, 1932, there was an attempted coup d’etat in Japan, led by a militant, nationalistic faction in the Imperial Army. The principal victim was the Japanese Prime Minister, Inukai Tsuyoshi. The perpetrators of the coup were given relatively light prison sentences, a pointer to the less democratic and belligerent Japan that would soon follow.

The bizarre element of the coup, which fortunately did not succeed, was a plan to murder the actor Charlie Chaplin. The thinking was that such a deed would incite popular fury in the US, and thus lead to war, in which Japan would prevail. At the time of the coup, Chaplin was watching a sumo wrestling match with the Prime Minister’s son, and thereby escaped the assassins.

This was more than lucky and in many ways Chaplin’s film The Great Dictator is a fine riposte to the destructive nationalism and totalitarianism that took hold across the world from the mid 1930’s. It is a film that still resonates today in our world of ‘predators’.

While our view of Japan today is of a placid, highly civilized country, its history in the past two centuries is a reminder of the pitfalls of isolationism, nationalism and war – concerns that are now echoing louder across the international political economy debate. It should be said at the same time that the post second world war relationship between the US and Japan is a good example of how two feuding countries can come together (Al Alletzhauser’s ‘House of Nomura’ is good on this topic).

Yet, such was Japan’s economic rebound after the second world war that America feared the rise of Japan as it now does China, and fans of economic history may know that during the 1980’s and 1990’s Donald Trump was an eminent Japan-trade basher. For instance, the April 13 1987 cover of Time magazine carried an image of Uncle Sam pitted against a sumo wrestler under the banner ‘Trade Wars – the US gets tough with Japan’ (the stock market crashed five months later).

Now, following decades lost to the after-effects of its economic crisis, Japan is undergoing an awakening, spearheaded by the historic election of the first female prime minister of Japan, Sanae Takaichi. This awakening takes different forms, a more assertive diplomatic stance on China, a ramping up of defence spending amidst greater public comfort with the idea of Japan as a budding military power. Also, Japan’s government is ambitious for its economy and has announced a record state budget of 122 trillion yen (over Eur 600 bn), and Japanese firms like Softbank are in the vanguard of the AI boom.

There are two other financial aspects of this awakening. In an attempt to revitalize the Japanese economy, the Bank of Japan had kept interest rates at or below zero for some time. It has abandoned that policy recently and with both growth and inflation picking up, bond yields have surged. For much of the last fifteen years, the ten-year bond yield in Japan has been well below 1%, but in 2024-25 normalised toward the 1.5-2% range, and is now 2.7%, whilst the longer term 30-year bond yield is 3.95%.

As one of the world’s most indebted countries (Japan’s headline public debt to GDP ratio is well over 200% according to the IMF), the effect of this is that fiscal policy is increasingly smothered by the effect of interest payments on that debt, and policy is trapped between trying to grow the economy, control inflation and not upset the bond market.

Equally the yen is grabbing attention, falling to a forty-year low this week. Indeed, it might well be lower, but traders are wary of a market intervention by the Japanese authorities. There are several factors driving this, the hedging of foreign exchange risk by investors buying Japanese assets, real interest rate differentials, and worries over the effects of expansionary fiscal policy. A costly bout of yen intervention might be close.

As Japan’s asset prices hit records for largely the wrong reasons, it serves as a reminder that many large indebted economies exist on a financial tightrope between growth and calamity. Britain is the most prominent example, but Japan is a more systematic case and over the summer could be the source of a market wobble, if not outright crisis as bond market sell-offs become more common in our ‘age of debt’.

It’s all enough to make me think of Charlie Chaplin’s depression era film Modern Times.

Have a great week ahead, Mike