Friday 13

Lagarde, Merkel

In the current panicked environment, it will not have escaped the attention of most people that last Friday fell on the 13th of the month. Friday 13th is typically seen as an omen of dark things to come, though its origin is more interesting than many will suspect.

Friday 13th October (1307) was the day that King Philip (le Bel) IV of France launched a lightening raid against the Knights Templar, imprisoning their Grand Master Jacques de Molay and many others. Philip was in debt to the Templars, whom he also feared for their military power and the clout of their pan-European financial network (they in many respects, invented banking as we know it).

The Templars were subjected to years of torture, the techniques of which prefigure the worst of the Inquisition and recent wars (i.e. water boarding). At the end of some seven years in captivity, Jacques de Molay was arraigned, and upon declaring that his only mistake was to renounce the Templars, he was carted off to be burnt at the stake (there is a memorial to him at the end of Ile de la Cité in Paris). Before dying, he cursed Philip and the Pope, both of whom died within the year.

While this tale is a good diversion from the ups and downs of the Dow, and to scare you the death of de Molay was followed thirty years later by the bubonic plague, it has made me think of the the link between torture/pain and one’s view of the world.

In de Molay’s day, torture quickly made the Templars recant their views, and in markets the same is true today. My first thought is of ECB President Christine Lagarde, who having been born in Paris should be familiar with the plight of the Templars.

On Thursday she stepped into the fire of markets by declaring that it was not the job of the ECB to close bond spreads. It was a brave statement, delivered at exactly the wrong time. Regular readers will know that I often rail against the ‘morphine’ that central banks have provided to economies and markets, and of the need to curb the oversized role of central banks. Lagarde, wisely I think, agrees and she has also expressed the view that European governments (especially Germany) need to be much more fiscally active.

By choosing to express this near heretical view, Lagarde risked monetary martyrdom, and disarray on the periphery of the European bond markets. I suspect that the pronounced and prolonged market volatility will produce a more generous and less thoughtful policy response from the ECB. We should expect a rate cut, more QE and liquidity intervention and I suspect more joint communiques with the Federal Reserve.

Lagarde is not alone in having her feet held to the fire of the market’s ire, Angela Merkel may be next. If there is a time for Germany to engage its borrowing power and fiscal surplus, it is now. Berlin needs to quickly communicate a plan to stimulate the German and by extension the European economy. This must also include ambitious structural objectives such as the need to a unified pan-European capital market, banking consolidation and a common approach to business start-ups across the EU.

If Merkel doesn’t act now, her career will be marked by banking collapses and rising unemployment. Like the network of the Templars, the future of the Union is at stake.

In the same way, the future of Donald Trump and the American approach to capitalism is also at stake. His administration is not the exemplar of the kind of big, responsive and diligent government that is necessary to defeat this crisis. Neither is big, responsive and diligent government something that can be conjured up in the short-run.

As market pain persists, I suspect that the Trump administration will increasingly turn ‘socialist’, and ask the private sector to take the strain of the coronavirus crisis (i.e. organizing testing, work from home and a less aggressive approach to layoffs), and will push for new monetary measures such as ‘helicopter money’ from the Federal Reserve. As the unfortunate Jacques de Molay found, pain can motivate great inventiveness.

Have a great week ahead,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s